Table 8. Comparison of defuzzification results between different weighting measures
Question item | Weighted by work experience | Weighted by business market | Weighted by job title |
R̃ = (a, b, c) | Defuzzification | Rank | R̃ = (a, b, c) | Defuzzification | Rank | R̃= (a, b, c) | Defuzzification | Rank |
a | b | c | a | b | c | a | b | c |
1 | 0.448989 | 0.648989 | 0.845629 | 0.648429 | 7 | 0.446647 | 0.646647 | 0.845322 | 0.646426 | 7 | 0.446086 | 0.646086 | 0.843636 | 0.645678 | 7 |
2 | 0.436884 | 0.635766 | 0.825442 | 0.634232 | 8 | 0.421550 | 0.619237 | 0.808346 | 0.617807 | 11 | 0.426044 | 0.624294 | 0.814525 | 0.622958 | 9 |
3 | 0.330201 | 0.530201 | 0.722462 | 0.528911 | 16 | 0.332026 | 0.532026 | 0.722210 | 0.530390 | 17 | 0.328655 | 0.528655 | 0.719401 | 0.527113 | 15 |
4 | 0.361047 | 0.558855 | 0.751834 | 0.558050 | 13 | 0.362245 | 0.559911 | 0.756958 | 0.559808 | 13 | 0.353818 | 0.551484 | 0.746284 | 0.551006 | 13 |
5 | 0.424344 | 0.623224 | 0.813943 | 0.621864 | 9 | 0.440758 | 0.638443 | 0.829192 | 0.637287 | 8 | 0.426151 | 0.624398 | 0.816832 | 0.623429 | 8 |
6 | 0.412863 | 0.611762 | 0.805426 | 0.610890 | 11 | 0.433117 | 0.630821 | 0.822481 | 0.629814 | 10 | 0.423567 | 0.621833 | 0.814054 | 0.620826 | 11 |
7 | 0.423020 | 0.621889 | 0.796375 | 0.617825 | 10 | 0.440527 | 0.638202 | 0.813799 | 0.634522 | 9 | 0.426201 | 0.624438 | 0.802282 | 0.621039 | 10 |
8 | 0.363439 | 0.562288 | 0.761560 | 0.562359 | 12 | 0.380376 | 0.578031 | 0.775582 | 0.578014 | 12 | 0.368016 | 0.566233 | 0.764346 | 0.566216 | 12 |
9 | 0.337648 | 0.529217 | 0.728005 | 0.530420 | 15 | 0.356613 | 0.551056 | 0.747526 | 0.551394 | 14 | 0.341164 | 0.533921 | 0.732076 | 0.534821 | 14 |
10 | 0.326243 | 0.525088 | 0.722813 | 0.524901 | 17 | 0.334641 | 0.532291 | 0.728751 | 0.532093 | 16 | 0.327056 | 0.525268 | 0.722852 | 0.525163 | 16 |
11 | 0.550216 | 0.750216 | 0.911409 | 0.743748 | 5 | 0.550583 | 0.750583 | 0.909689 | 0.743767 | 5 | 0.549459 | 0.749459 | 0.910812 | 0.743018 | 5 |
12 | 0.537461 | 0.737461 | 0.909646 | 0.732825 | 6 | 0.541739 | 0.741739 | 0.903872 | 0.735428 | 6 | 0.531065 | 0.731065 | 0.902748 | 0.726346 | 6 |
13 | 0.564071 | 0.764071 | 0.901942 | 0.753716 | 3 | 0.582197 | 0.782197 | 0.913799 | 0.770797 | 3 | 0.573489 | 0.773489 | 0.905653 | 0.762183 | 3 |
14 | 0.553827 | 0.753827 | 0.919623 | 0.748126 | 4 | 0.557549 | 0.757549 | 0.921400 | 0.751524 | 4 | 0.558954 | 0.758954 | 0.922805 | 0.752929 | 4 |
15 | 0.594548 | 0.794548 | 0.937778 | 0.785086 | 1 | 0.594790 | 0.794790 | 0.936560 | 0.785085 | 1 | 0.594790 | 0.794790 | 0.937122 | 0.785179 | 1 |
16 | 0.588041 | 0.788041 | 0.940094 | 0.780050 | 2 | 0.592059 | 0.792059 | 0.941144 | 0.783573 | 2 | 0.589250 | 0.789250 | 0.941706 | 0.781326 | 2 |
17 | 0.302881 | 0.502881 | 0.697505 | 0.501985 | 18 | 0.282455 | 0.482455 | 0.678445 | 0.481787 | 18 | 0.293691 | 0.493691 | 0.689119 | 0.492929 | 18 |
18 | 0.336403 | 0.534313 | 0.723568 | 0.532871 | 14 | 0.340268 | 0.536386 | 0.724547 | 0.535060 | 15 | 0.328470 | 0.524588 | 0.713873 | 0.523449 | 17 |