Table 8. Comparison of defuzzification results between different weighting measures

Question item Weighted by work experience Weighted by business market Weighted by job title
R̃ = (a, b, c) Defuzzification Rank R̃ = (a, b, c) Defuzzification Rank R̃= (a, b, c) Defuzzification Rank
a b c a b c a b c
1 0.448989 0.648989 0.845629 0.648429 7 0.446647 0.646647 0.845322 0.646426 7 0.446086 0.646086 0.843636 0.645678 7
2 0.436884 0.635766 0.825442 0.634232 8 0.421550 0.619237 0.808346 0.617807 11 0.426044 0.624294 0.814525 0.622958 9
3 0.330201 0.530201 0.722462 0.528911 16 0.332026 0.532026 0.722210 0.530390 17 0.328655 0.528655 0.719401 0.527113 15
4 0.361047 0.558855 0.751834 0.558050 13 0.362245 0.559911 0.756958 0.559808 13 0.353818 0.551484 0.746284 0.551006 13
5 0.424344 0.623224 0.813943 0.621864 9 0.440758 0.638443 0.829192 0.637287 8 0.426151 0.624398 0.816832 0.623429 8
6 0.412863 0.611762 0.805426 0.610890 11 0.433117 0.630821 0.822481 0.629814 10 0.423567 0.621833 0.814054 0.620826 11
7 0.423020 0.621889 0.796375 0.617825 10 0.440527 0.638202 0.813799 0.634522 9 0.426201 0.624438 0.802282 0.621039 10
8 0.363439 0.562288 0.761560 0.562359 12 0.380376 0.578031 0.775582 0.578014 12 0.368016 0.566233 0.764346 0.566216 12
9 0.337648 0.529217 0.728005 0.530420 15 0.356613 0.551056 0.747526 0.551394 14 0.341164 0.533921 0.732076 0.534821 14
10 0.326243 0.525088 0.722813 0.524901 17 0.334641 0.532291 0.728751 0.532093 16 0.327056 0.525268 0.722852 0.525163 16
11 0.550216 0.750216 0.911409 0.743748 5 0.550583 0.750583 0.909689 0.743767 5 0.549459 0.749459 0.910812 0.743018 5
12 0.537461 0.737461 0.909646 0.732825 6 0.541739 0.741739 0.903872 0.735428 6 0.531065 0.731065 0.902748 0.726346 6
13 0.564071 0.764071 0.901942 0.753716 3 0.582197 0.782197 0.913799 0.770797 3 0.573489 0.773489 0.905653 0.762183 3
14 0.553827 0.753827 0.919623 0.748126 4 0.557549 0.757549 0.921400 0.751524 4 0.558954 0.758954 0.922805 0.752929 4
15 0.594548 0.794548 0.937778 0.785086 1 0.594790 0.794790 0.936560 0.785085 1 0.594790 0.794790 0.937122 0.785179 1
16 0.588041 0.788041 0.940094 0.780050 2 0.592059 0.792059 0.941144 0.783573 2 0.589250 0.789250 0.941706 0.781326 2
17 0.302881 0.502881 0.697505 0.501985 18 0.282455 0.482455 0.678445 0.481787 18 0.293691 0.493691 0.689119 0.492929 18
18 0.336403 0.534313 0.723568 0.532871 14 0.340268 0.536386 0.724547 0.535060 15 0.328470 0.524588 0.713873 0.523449 17